Blog Archive

The Pazyryk Kurgans: a Glimpse into the Amazing World of Central Asia in the Iron Age (I millennium BCE)

Regular Posts13 CommentsWar and Conflict

I am back from my last travels within the fair island of Ireland. A lot of impressions, ideas, and topics to blog about. Unfortunately, experience shows that while I travel I simply don’t have the leisure to post. As a result, this blog has been sadly neglected. Now that I am back home, however, I expect I will be able to resume blogging at my regular rate (until I go away on another trip...).

The next few blogs will probably be devoted to what I have seen in my recent travels. One of the highlights was a tour of the symbolic landscape in Belfast. Today, however, I want to write about my visit to the Hermitage Museum in St. Petersburg:

(all photos by the author)

The Hermitage is one of the oldest and largest world museums. One can easily spend a week exploring it. I only had half a day, so I focused on the Hermitage collection devoted to the history of Siberian and Central Asian cultures. The rooms housing this collection are located in one of the farthest, and most difficult to reach corners of the Winter Palace (the residence of Russian emperors). I had to follow a circuitous route, which involved going up one floor, wending my way through an endless sequence of luxurious halls, and locating a staircase that would take me down back to the first floor.

There were throngs of tourists queuing up to enter the museum (we bought tickets on the internet, and were able to bypass the line; the additional benefit was the permission to take pictures, as long as no flash was used).

But the Central Asian rooms were deserted – few people were able (or interested enough) to get this far. But if you have an interest in the history of Central Asia (as I do), this was indeed the jackpot.

Most people think of the nomads of Central Asia as rude barbarians, far below the level of civilization achieved by their neighbors, who built the first mega-empires, such as the Achaemenid Persia and the Han China. The facts are quite different. Not only were the Central Asians supreme in inventing the most powerful military technologies of the Ancient and Medieval Eras (primarily having to do with horse-based warfare), they also produced some of the most consequential ideological innovations (including the Monotheism and the Mandate of Heaven). They also produced a very elaborate material culture.

We know this thanks to a peculiar property of burial monuments (Kurgans, or barrows) of the chieftains of the so-called Pazyryk culture (sixth to third century BCE in the Altay region). By chance or design, these barrows suck cold air during the winters and retain it in summers. As a result, the burial goods are permanently frozen, so that the organic materials – cloth, wood, horn, leather – have been preserved until they were excavated by modern archaeologists.

One of the most spectacular finds is the huge felt carpet from the Fifth Pazyryk Kurgan:

This carpet was made with the base of thin white felt (3 mm thick). On top of the base, the ancient masters sewed figures cut from colored felts. The carpet repeats the same scene: a horseman approaches a female deity holding a flowering branch. Here's the detail showing the horseman:

The chieftain who was buried in the Fifth Pazyryk Kurgan was about 55 years old. His mummy was prepared before burial by removing entrails and brain, and shaving most of his hair.

It's a bit of a pathetic fate for this man, who clearly was a powerful and respected warrior in his life, to be now a subject of idle curiosity of throngs of tourists ...

On the other hand, the chief buried in the Fifth Kurgan was luckier than the one in the Second Kurgan. The Fifth Kurgan's chief probably died of natural causes (in the last years of his life he had some degenerative disease that limited his mobility). By contrast, the Second Kurgan's chief was killed by his enemies. His head was cut off and scalped:

head

Note the vertical cut on his forehead - this was probably the sword cut that killed him. After his death, the victors punched holes in his cut-off head:

They probably used the holes to pass a leather thong so that his head could be hanged from the saddle of his victor. Somehow the relatives/retinue of the vanquished chief were able to recover his head, so that he could be buried with appropriate honors in the Second Kurgan. There is clearly a great story here - for someone like Neal Stephenson to flesh out (no pun intended).

Incidentally, all noble chiefs were elaborately tattooed:

Another fine example of Pazyryk art is the saddlecloth from the First Kurgan:

It uses a similar technique to the one in the great felt carpet. However, the Pazyryk artisans also knew how to make true woven carpets. The oldest pile carpet known to archaeologists was made in Altay between the sixth and third centuries BCE:

Finally, I've got to include a picture of at least one horse mask:

Lest the readers think that Iron Age Central Asians only excelled at ornamental arts, I should point out that they had very skillful weapon-makers (e.g., bowyers) and blacksmiths. They also had a remarkable grasp of mechanical arts, as illustrated by the four-wheeled cart, made from birchwood, found disassembled in the kurgan:

 

 

 

Blog Archive Comments 13 comments Comments originally published with this post. This archive is read-only.
  1. Gene Anderson

    Yep, it's amazing stuff. The "barbarian" label is due to two successive waves of prejudice: first, the Byzantines in the west and Chinese in the east got out the war propaganda saying these guys were just uncouth nomads, and, second, Enlightenment and Victorian historians in the western world then added their own prejudices against "backward" and "nomadic" societies. The result has been surprisingly persistent misrepresentation.

    1. Peter Turchin

      Lev Gumilev, a Russian historian of Central Asia, called it "The Black Legend" (how the nomads were denigrated by the agrarian people).

  2. rick tendys

    Thank you,.....worth waiting for You know what really confuses me is that those brilliant forward thinking communists in Cuba China Nth Korea etc (dare I say Aust).....did NOT wipe out that evil memorial of ....art, intellect and history.in the hermitage.........the modern muslims would have cleaned it up with a 25 gun salute and sleep soundly as having done allahs work well hell man he is a busy body (....??.......)..we have to help him... hey man any god who creates a universe needs all the help he can get

    1. Peter Turchin

      Sadly, the Bolsheviks did sell off some of the art collected by the Tsars. Don't remember how that affected the Hermitage.

  3. Jack Pedersen

    There are two things that continue to amaze me, having lived in the Republic of Tyva at the time of the major Scythian discoveries of Arzhaan. Firstly the east-west extent of that culture from at least Tyva to at least Bilsk in Ukraine, a scythian city covering 40 sq km,, and Tillia Tepe in between. Then as a linguist the revelation that the Tocharians of the Gobi region spoke a western indo-european language and were apparently caucasians, says something about our blinkered view of mainstream history. Revision needed!

    1. Peter Turchin

      Indeed, during the Iron Age the whole of the Great Steppe looks highly culturally unified. The Hunnu (Xingnu, Hsiungnu) have essentially the same material culture as the Scythians many thousands of kilometers to the West. One of the best recent summaries is Chris Beckwiths' Empires of the Silk Road - check it out, if you haven't read it already.

  4. O.Voron

    I visited the Hermitage more than once and have never seen this amazing collection:( If I ever happen to be there again, I will make sure to reach the Pazyryk rooms

    1. Peter Turchin

      Well worth the visit. My photographs caputre only a tiny fraction of what's there.

  5. O.Voron

    Scythian Ice Maiden - Indo-Europeans in the Altai. BBC https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YDQgMCmnBNw

  6. O.Voron

    Chariot Eastern Altai, Pazyryk Burial Mound 5 5th-4th centuries BC http://www.hermitagemuseum.org/html_En/03/hm3_2_7e.html

  7. vdinets

    There is an interesting sequel of The Lord of the Rings, titled The Last Ring-bearer, written by K. Es'kov, a Russian paleontologist. Its idea is that Tolkien's book is an epic story written by peoples of the western Middle Earth and skewed in the same way as Black Legend-skewed history of Central Asia. In reality, Mordor was just a different civilization, sacked and then vilified by its conquerors. In the sequel, a few valiant orcs try to save Middle Earth from evil elves' domination. An English translation has been recently published online somewhere.

    1. Igor Demić

      You shouldn't have posted this vdinets, now I'm hooked! And I don't have time to get hooked on fiction right now :-) The author writes great prose and the idea is great (how come I didn't think of that?). I searched the author a bit. I read something about him being an anti-evolutionist. I hope I misread that. Anyway, thanks for the recommendation.

      1. vdinets

        You are welcome. No, he isn't an anti-evolutionist as far as I know.

Connections

Related work

Book

War and Peace and War

Feb 27, 2007Turchin, P.

Empires rise and fall, populations and economies boom and bust, world religions spread or wither…

In War and Peace and War, Peter Turchin uses his expertise in evolutionary biology to offer a bold new theory about the course of world history. Turchin argues that the key to the formation of an empire is a society’s capacity for collective action. He demonstrates that high levels of cooperation are found where people have to band together to fight off…

PlumeStates and EmpiresWar and Conflict
Publication

Landscape of fear: indirect effects of conflict can account for large-scale population declines in non-state societies

Aug 28, 2024Dániel Kondor, James S. Bennett, Detlef Gronenborn, et al.

The impact of inter-group conflict on population dynamics has long been debated, especially for prehistoric and non-state societies. In this work, we consider that beyond direct battle casualties, conflicts can also create a ‘landscape of fear’ in which many non-combatants near theatres of conflict abandon their homes and migrate away. This process causes population decline in the abandoned regions and increased stress on local resources in better-protected areas that are targeted by refugees. By applying analytical and computational modelling, we demonstrate that these indirect effects of conflict are sufficient to produce substantial, long-term population boom-and-bust patterns in non-state societies, such as the case of Mid-Holocene Europe. We also demonstrate that greater availability of defensible locations act to protect and maintain the supply of combatants, increasing the permanence of the landscape of fear and the likelihood of endemic warfare.

Journal of The Royal Society InterfaceWar and ConflictSocial Complexity
Publication

Empirically Testing Predictions of an Attrition Warfare Model for the War in Ukraine

Dec 10, 2023Turchin, P.

The goal of this study is to empirically test hypotheses about wars of attrition by evaluating their predictions for the conflict in Ukraine. Evaluation will occur after the war is over and authoritative data sources become available for analysis. This pre-registration document presents two quantitative hypotheses that make opposite predictions about the course of the War in Ukraine: (1) the Economic Power hypothesis, which predicts a win for Ukraine and (2) the Casualties Rates hypothesis, which predicts a win for Russia. Additionally, I consider an alternative hypothesis, according to which the outcome will be determined by random unforeseen events. The document includes four main parts: 1. An introduction providing the conceptual background and the rationale for this study. 2. The mathematical framework and a computational model that incorporates both Economic Power and Casualties Rates hypotheses as special cases. 3. An analysis plan that defines model outputs (what is predicted) and model inputs (parameter values and initial conditions), which need to be estimated from data. 4. An interim assessment (as of Summer 2023) using non-authoritative sources illustrating how, after the end of the war, input parameters will be estimated and the accuracy of predictions assessed. At the time of pre-registration (November 2023) the conflict is still unresolved. Neither side has made significant territorial gains for over a year (since the late Fall of 2022). Furthermore, no authoritative source for data, needed to accurately estimate inputs, is currently available. Estimates published in the press differ wildly depending on the source. As a consequence, the alternative predictions discussed in the interim assessment should not be taken as predicting the future course of the conflict. They instead are meant to demonstrate how these specific scientific hypotheses about war dynamics will be assessed after the war concludes.

SocArXiv PreprintWar and ConflictCliodynamics
Publication

Landscape of Fear: Indirect effects of conflict can account for large-scale population declines in non-state societies

Oct 19, 2023Daniel Kondor, James S. Bennett, Detlef Gronenborn, et al.

The impact of inter-group conflict on population dynamics has long been debated, especially for prehistoric and non-state societies. In this work, we consider that beyond direct battle casualties, conflicts can also create a “landscape of fear” in which many non-combatants near theaters of conflict abandon their homes and migrate away. This process causes population decline in the abandoned regions and increased stress on local resources in better protected areas that are targeted by refugees. By applying analytical and computational modeling, we demonstrate that these indirect effects of conflict are sufficient to produce substantial, long-term population boom-and-bust patterns in non-state societies, such as the case of Mid-Holocene Europe. We also demonstrate that greater availability of defensible locations, by acting to protect and maintain the supply of combatants, increases the permanence of the landscape of fear and the likelihood of endemic warfare.

SocArXiv PreprintWar and ConflictSocial Complexity
Publication

Empirically Testing and Refining Structural Demographic Theory: A Methodological Guide

Jun 24, 2023Peter Turchin, Daniel Hoyer

Are human societies dynamical systems? Can they be studied—and, perhaps, to a degree predicted—with the methods of complexity science, such as agent-based models and big data analytics? If yes, what are the limits to prediction? A particularly challenging question is, can we forecast the dynamics of societal resilience and its obverse, sociopolitical unrest or even breakdown? So far efforts to predict onset of rebellions and civil wars using theory-free big data approaches have proved unsuccessful. An alternative approach, based on Structural-Demographic Theory (SDT), which integrates mechanism-based models with data and focuses on the dynamics of structural drivers for instability over the long-term (thus, requiring a historical approach), has shown better promise. Specifically, several recent studies utilizing the SDT framework have proven adept at predicting (or “retrodicting”) sociopolitical instability in c.20 past societies. It was also used in 2010 to successfully forecast outbreak of US instability 10 years in the future (in 2020). Collectively, this work is producing a growing body of evidence showcasing the ability of SDT-based approaches to uncover critical societal dynamics in the deep past as well as more contemporary cases. The next step in these efforts is to employ these insights towards the future. Here, we outline the SDT approach and document how it can be employed to explore the dynamics of any number of past and contemporary societies, appealing to researchers to pursue this line of research in as many cases as possible. The overall goal of this research is to empirically test SDT in a most rigorous way, using it to forecast coming periods of unrest. Because the theory is likely to fail in many ways, the second goal is to learn from these errors so that we can further refine the theory (or develop better-working alternatives). Specifically, we will learn: (1) how accurately (if at all) does the SDT framework predict future levels of sociopolitical instability (integrating incidence of antigovernment demonstrations, violent riots, and armed conflict); (2) What are the relative contributions of possible drivers of instability, including those proposed by SDT, as well as other theories, in explaining instability levels; and (3) are there key ‘leverage points’ that might help mitigate the negative consequences of instability?

SocArXiv PreprintStructural-Demographic TheoryPolitical Instability
Publication

War and the origins of Chinese civilization

Apr 22, 2023Zhiwu Chen, Peter Turchin, Wanda Wang

Why did complex societies, characterized by densely-populated walled cities, first arise in northern China, jump-starting early Chinese civilization? We explore this question in three steps. First, the North, especially the alluvial plains along the Yellow and the Yangtze Rivers, had generally flatter terrains than the South. Second, by dividing China’s landmass into 100 km ×100 km grid-cells and using our archaeological database, we demonstrate that cells with flatter terrains faced higher war threats in prehistoric and early historic times, where war threats are respectively proxied by each cell’s number of excavated military grave goods for the Neolithic period (8000−1700 BCE) and by its number of recorded conflicts for the Eastern Zhou (770−221 BCE, the earliest period for which war data are available). Third, we establish that during both the Neolithic and the Eastern Zhou, higher war threats led to the construction of more settlements with defensive walls and moats, resulting in more walled cities (i.e., early cradles of civilization). Thus, warfare was a key driver of the evolution of complex societies. This finding is robust after controlling for irrigation potential, agricultural productivity, and threats from the steppe, as well as under alternative specifications.

SSRN Electronic JournalWar and ConflictSocial Complexity