2012–2025

Search the Blog Archive

Search by title, subject, or tag, or filter by date.

Exploring Alternative Ancient Histories: a Guest Post by James Bennett

Blog Archive
Jan 29, 2022

The brilliant atomic physicist Enrico Fermi was notorious for unnerving PhD candidates during their oral examinations by asking ‘How many piano tuners are there in the city of Chicago?’ The point of the question, besides the psychological effect, was to…

Guest Posts

A bad time for (some) theories but a good time for history?

Blog Archive
May 5, 2019

A guest post by Harvey Whitehouse and Pieter Francois This is an interesting moment in the development of history as an academic discipline. We stand on the brink of a sea change, not necessarily in the way historical evidence is gathered and documented, but…

Guest Posts

Lessons from the Past: What Political Violence of the 1970s Tells Us about 2017

Blog Archive
Feb 11, 2017

A Guest Post by David Hines At the start of 2017, America looks to be in for a stretch of serious political turmoil. Accordingly, it makes sense to look at previous such period to see what lessons can be learned.…

Guest Posts

Herbert Gintis: Societies whose business leaders have moral integrity are successful societies (a guest blog)

Blog Archive
Jan 16, 2016

I spent several instructive days with Branko Milanovic at the Santa Fe Institute, but we did not discuss this interesting issue (see The Iron Logic of Gordon Gekko ). It is worthwhile discussing it in this forum.…

Guest Posts

Branko Milanovic: The Iron Logic of Gordon Gekko (a guest post)

Blog Archive
Jan 14, 2016

Dear Peter, I am on my way to Moscow and just read the first three chapters of your book. Let me now give you my first reaction because I am afraid I might go back to the rest of the book only in a week or so (i.e., after Moscow, since my program in Moscow…

Guest Posts

Fire and Paleo Diet: Loren Cordain Responds

Blog Archive
Dec 9, 2015

Thanks Peter for bringing this issue to your blog readers. Here are a couple of important points which you and/or your readers should address when evaluating Richard Wrangham’s hypothesis that the control of fire and subsequent consumption of cooked tubers…

Guest Posts
Blog Archive

Scott Atran. Psychology, Anthropology, and a Science of Human Beings

Jan 22, 2015

The following reflection on the problems of psychology, anthropology, and a science of human beings has been stimulated by recent responses to a couple of recent articles in Nature ( Looking for the Roots of Terrorism and Psychologists Seek Roots of Terror…

Guest Posts
Blog Archive

Carl Coon. One Step at a Time

Nov 21, 2014

Evolution is a process that proceeds incrementally, one step at a time. One thing leads to another. This is true for all kinds of evolution. Living things evolve through natural selection, with small changes between generations leading to larger changes…

Guest Posts
Blog Archive

Seshat: What Studying War Is Good for? A guest blog by Edward A. L. Turner.

Aug 2, 2014

Seshat: The Global History Databank is a game-changing database construction project that may reveal there is actually one thing war is good for: historical statistics.…

Guest Posts
Blog Archive

Joe Brewer: Linguistic Framing of “War! What is it Good For?”

Jul 24, 2014

Peter Turchin recently posted an article on the Forum about the role of war in cultural evolution that stimulated a lively, yet largely discordant, conversation.…

Guest Posts
Blog Archive

A World Without Poverty. A guest blog by Joe Brewer

Apr 27, 2014

Imagine a world without poverty. What would it look like? Is it even possible? How do we get there? When people working at foundations, nonprofit organizations, and government agencies dive into this topic, they typically do so with the assumption that…

Guest Posts
Blog Archive

Andrey Korotayev: Anatomy of the Egyptian Counterrevolution, Part II

Mar 27, 2014

As I wrote in the first part, one factor underlying the success of the 2001 Egyptian Revolution was strong intraelite conflict. The second factor that lead to an unexpectedly fast success of the protestors was the formation of a wide opposition alliance,…

Guest Posts
Blog Archive

Andrey Korotayev: Anatomy of the Egyptian Counterrevolution

Mar 25, 2014

Our young Egyptian friends (a sort of “leftist liberal revolutionaries”) consider the post-July 3 events in their country [the ousting of president Morsi by the military] as “counterrevolution”.…

Guest Posts
Blog Archive

Ideology Is Heritable Yet Societies Can Change Their Views Quickly. A guest blog by Jonathan Haidt.

Dec 16, 2013

Bernard Winograd has written an intriguing post , summarizing the findings one must grapple with when thinking about how attitudes can change within a single generation.…

Guest Posts
Blog Archive

We Really Have no Idea Why Political Attitudes Change (or Not). A Guest Blog by Bernard Winograd

Dec 14, 2013

At the risk of oversimplification, consider a few key findings of researchers into human beliefs and their evolutionary foundations. • Human belief systems are rooted in biologically evolved senses of morality.…

Guest Posts
Blog Archive

John Kemp. Where Are We Now? On Gauguin, His Questions, and Models of History

Oct 7, 2013

In his book, The Social Conquest of Earth , E.O. Wilson repeated three questions originally posed by Paul Gauguin: Where did we come from? What are we? Where are we going?…

Guest Posts
Blog Archive

Bryan Vila: A Criminologist Comments on ‘Canaries in a Coal Mine’

Dec 18, 2012

Hello Peter, I've read the blog post and think it's an interesting and well-presented idea. But before the evolutionary-ecologist/criminologist/historian in me could accept this as plausible, I'd want to account for three sets of causal forces.…

Guest Posts
Blog Archive

Joe Anoatubby: Cycles of violence in the United States

Aug 8, 2012

I’ve always made argument with my colleagues and students that there are indeed cyclical patterns in US History. I also believe that part of that phenomenon is related to the reality that younger generations lose touch with the implications of violence and…

Guest Posts